"Your friends aren't going anywhere, sir. And neither, I might add, are you." Inspector Springer signalled his constables forward.
"How wonderful! You'd take us prisoners, too! Have you any weapons, like the Lats? You must produce something, Inspector, to rival their effects, unless you wish to be absolutely outshone!"
"I thought these Latvians were on your side," said Sergeant Sherwood.
"Indeed, no! What would be the fun of that?"
"You say they're destroying everything. Rape, pillage, murder?"
"Exactly."
"Well, I never…" Inspector Springer scratched his head. "So you're merely the foils of these people, instead o' the other way about?"
"I think there's a misunderstanding, Inspector," said Mrs. Underwood. "You see…"
"Misunderstanding!" Suddenly Harold Underwood lurched towards her. "Jezebel!"
"Harold!"
"Ha!"
There came another boom, louder than the previous ones, and the ceiling vanished to reveal the sky.
"It can only be the Lat," said Bishop Castle, with the air of an expert. "You really must come with me. Jherek and Amelia, unless you want to be destroyed before you have enjoyed any of the fun." He began to lead them towards his air-car at the window. "There'll be nothing left of our world, at this rate!"
"Do they really mean to destroy you all?" asked the time-traveller, as they went by.
"I gather not. They originally came for prisoners. Mistress Christia, of course," this to Jherek, "is now a captive. I think it's their habit to go about the galaxy killing the males and abducting the females."
"You'll let them?" Mrs. Underwood enquired.
"What do you mean?"
"You won't stop this?"
"Oh, eventually, I suppose we'll have to. Mistress Christia wouldn't be happy in space. Particularly if it has become as bleak as Mongrove reports."
"What do you say, Amelia? Shall we go and watch? Join in?" Jherek wanted to know.
"Of course not."
He suppressed his disappointment.
"Perhaps you wish me to be abducted by those creatures?" she said.
"Indeed, no!"
"Perhaps it would be better to return in my Chronomnibus," suggested the time-traveller, "at least until —"
"Amelia?"
She shook her head. "The circumstances are too shameful for me. Respectable society would be closed to me now."
"Then you will stay, dearest Amelia?"
"Mr. Carnelian, this is no time to continue with your pesterings. I will accept that I am an outcast, but I still have certain standards of behaviour. Besides, I am concerned for Harold. He is not himself. And for that, we are to blame. Well, perhaps not you, really — but I must accept a large share of guilt. I should have been firmer. I should not have admitted my love —" and she burst into tears.
"You do admit it, then, Amelia!"
"You are heartless, Mr. Carnelian," she sobbed, "and scarcely tactful…"
"Ha!" said Harold Underwood. "It is just as well that I have already begun divorce proceedings…"
"Excellent!" cried Jherek.
Another boom.
"My machine!" exclaimed the time-traveller, and ran outside.
"Take cover, men." Inspector Springer called. They all lay down.
Bishop Castle was already in his air-car, surrounded by a cloud of dust. "Are you coming, Jherek?"
"I think not. I hope you enjoy yourself, Bishop Castle."
"I shall. I shall." The air-car began to rise, Charon's barge, into the upper atmosphere.
Only Mr. and Mrs. Underwood and Jherek Carnelian remained standing, in the ruins of the palace. "Come," said Jherek to them both, "I think I know where we can find safety." He turned a power-ring. His old air-car, the locomotive, materialized. It was in gleaming red and black now, but lime-coloured smoke still puffed from its stack. "Forgive the lack of invention," he said to them, "but as we are in haste…"
"You would save Harold, too?" she said, as Jherek helped her husband aboard.
"Why not? You say you are concerned for him." He grinned cheerfully, while overhead a searing, scarlet bolt of pure energy went roaring by, "Besides, I wish to hear the details of this divorce he plans. Is that not the ceremony that must take place before we can be married?"
She made no reply to this, as she joined him on the footplate. "Where are we going, Mr. Carnelian?"
The locomotive began to puff skyward. "I'm full of old smokies," he sang, "I'm covered in dough. I've eaten blue plovers and I'm snorting up coke!" Mr. Underwood clutched the rail and stared down at the ruins they left behind. His knees were shaking. "It's a railroad song, from your own time," Jherek explained. "Would you like to be the fireman?"
He offered Mr. Underwood the platinum shovel. Mr. Underwood accepted the shovel without a word and, mechanically, began to stoke coal into the fire-chamber.
"Mr. Carnelian! Where are we going?"
"To certain safety, dearest Amelia. To certain safety, I assure you."
15. In Which Jherek Carnelian and Mrs. Underwood find Sanctuary of Sorts, and Mr. Underwood Makes a New Friend
"You are not disturbed, dearest Amelia, by this city?"
"I find the place improbable. I failed to realize, listening only to talk of such settlements, how vast and how, well, how unlike cities they were!"
Mr. Underwood stood some distance away, on the other side of the little plaza. Green globes of fuzzy light, about the size of tennis balls, ran up and down his outstretched arms; he watched them with childlike delight; behind him the air was black, purple, dark green shot with crimson, as chemicals expanded and contracted in a kind of simulation of breathing, giving off their vapours; bronze sparks showered nearby, pinkish energy arced from one tower to another; steel sang. The city murmured to itself, almost asleep, certainly drowsy. Even the narrow rivulets of mercury, criss-crossing the ground at their feet, seemed to be running slowly.
"The cities protect themselves," Jherek explained. "I have seen it before. No weapon can operate within them, no weapon can harm them from without, because they can always command more energy than any weapon brought against them, you see. It was part of their original design."
"This resembles a manufactory more than it does a township," she remarked.
"It is actually," he told her, "more in the nature of a museum. There are several such cities on the planet; they contain what remains of our knowledge."
"These fumes — are they not poisonous?"
"Not to Man. They could not be."
She accepted his assurance, but continued wary, as he led them from the plaza, through an arcade of lurid yellow and mauve metallic fronds, faintly reminiscent of those they had seen in the Palaeozoic; a strange greyish light fell through the fronds and distorted their shadows. Mr. Underwood wandered some distance behind them, softly singing.
"We must consider," she whispered, "how Harold is to be saved."
"Saved for what?"
"From his insanity."
"He seems happier in the city."
"He believes himself in Hell, no doubt. Just as I once believed. Inspector Springer should never have brought him."
"I am not altogether sure that the inspector is quite himself."
"I agree, Mr. Carnelian. All this smacks of political panic at home. There is thought to be considerable interest in Spiritualism and Freemasonry among certain members of the Cabinet, at the present time. There is even some talk that the Prince of Wales…"
She continued in this vein for a while, mystifying him entirely. Her information, he gathered, was gleaned from a broadsheet which Mr. Underwood had once acquired.
The arcade gave way to a chasm running between high, featureless buildings, their walls covered with chemical stains and peculiar semi-biological growths, some of which palpitated; ahead of them was something globular, glowing and dark, which rolled away from them as they advanced and, as they reached the end of the chasm, vanished. Here the vista widened and they could see across a plain littered with half-rotted metal relics to where, in the distance, angry flames spread themselves against an invisible wall.
"There!" he said. "That must be the Lat's weapons at work. The city throws up its defences. See, I told you that we should be safe, dear Amelia."
She glanced over her shoulder to where her husband sat upon a structure that seemed part of stone and part of some kind of hardened resin. "I wish you would try to be more tactful, Mr. Carnelian. Remember that my husband is within earshot. Consider his feelings, if you will not consider mine!"
"But he has relinquished you to me. He said as much. By your customs that is sufficient, is it not?"
"He divorces me, that is all. I have a right to choose or reject any husband I please."
"Of course. But you choose me. I know."
"I have not told you that."
"You have, Amelia. You forget. You have mentioned more than once that you love me."
"That does not mean — would not mean — that I would necessarily marry you, Mr. Carnelian. There is still every chance that I may return to Bromley — or at least to my own time."
"Where you will be an outcast. You said so."
"In Bromley. Not everywhere." But she frowned. "I can imagine the scandal. The newspapers will have published something, to be sure. Oh, dear."
"You seemed to be enjoying life at the End of Time."
"Perhaps I would continue to do so, Mr. Carnelian, were I not haunted, very definitely, by the Past." Another glance over her shoulder. "How is one ever to relax?"
"This is a fluke. It is the first time anything like it has ever occurred here."
"Besides, I would remind you that, according to Bishop Castle (not to mention the evidence of our own eyes) your world is being destroyed about your ears."
"For the moment, only. It can soon be replaced."
"Lord Mongrove and Yusharisp would have us believe otherwise."
"It is hard to take them seriously."
"For you, perhaps. Not for me, Mr. Carnelian. What they say makes considerable sense."
" Opportunities for redemption must therefore be few in such an ambience as you describe ," said quite another voice, a low, mellow, slightly sleepy voice.
"There are none," said Mr. Underwood, "at least that I know of."
" That is interesting. I seem to recall something of the theory, but most of the information I would require was stored elsewhere, in a sister city, whose co-ordinates I cannot quite recollect. I am of a mind to believe, however, that you are either a manifestation of this city's delusions (which proliferate notoriously, these days) or else that you are deluded yourself, a victim of too much morbid fascination with ancient mythologies. I could be mistaken — there was a time when I was infallible, I think. I am not sure that your description of this city tallies with the facts which remain at my command. You could argue, I know, that I myself am deluded as to the truth, yet my evidence would seem to tally with my instincts, whereas you, yourself, make intellectual rather than instinctive assumptions; that at least is what I gather from the illogicalities so far expressed in your analysis. You have contradicted yourself at least three times since you sat down on my shell ."
It was the compound of rock and resin that spoke. "One form of memory bank," murmured Jherek. "There are so many kinds, not always immediately recognizable."
" I think ," continued the bank, " that you are still confused and have not yet ordered your thoughts sufficiently to communicate properly with me. I assure you that I will function much more satisfactorily if you phrase your remarks better ."
Mr. Underwood did not seem offended by this criticism. "I think you are right," he said. "I am confused. Well, I am mad, to be blunt."
" Madness may only be the expression of ordinary emotional confusion. Fear of madness can cause, I believe, a retreat into the very madness one fears. This is only superficially a paradox. Madness may be said to be a tendency to simplify, into easily grasped metaphors, the nature of the world. In your own case, you have plainly been confounded by unexpected complexities, therefore you are inclined to retreat into simplification — this talk of Damnation and Hell, for instance — to create a world whose values are unambivalent, unequivocal. It is a pity that so few of my own ancestors survive for they, by their very nature, would have responded better to your views. On the other hand it may be that you are not content with this madness, that you would rather face the complexities, feel at ease with them. If so, I am sure that I can help, in a small way ."
"You are very kind," said Mr. Underwood.
" Nonsense. I am glad to be of service. I have had nothing to do for the best part of a million years. I was in danger of growing 'rusty'. Luckily, having no mechanical parts, I can remain dormant for a long time without any especially deleterious effects. Though, as part of a very complex system, there is much information I can no longer call upon ."
"Then you are of the opinion that this is not the afterlife, that I am not here as punishment for my sins, that I shall not be here for eternity, that I am not, as it were, dead."
" You are certainly not dead, for you can still converse, feel, think and experience physical needs and discomforts… "
The bank had a penchant for abstract conversation which seemed to suit Mr. Underwood, though Jherek and Amelia became quickly bored listening to it. "It reminds me of an old schoolmaster I once had," she whispered, and she grinned. "It is just what Harold needs really, at present."
The vivid splashes of light no longer spread across the horizon and the scene darkened. No sun could be observed in the lurid sky, across which clouds of queerly coloured gases perpetually drifted. Behind them, the city seemed to stir, shuddering with age and strain, groaning almost complainingly.
"What would happen to you if your cities collapsed?" she asked him.
"That is impossible. They are self-perpetuating."
"There is no evidence of that." Even as she spoke, two of the metallic structures fell into the dust and became dust themselves.
"Yet they are," he told her. "In their own way. They have been like this for millennia, somehow surviving. We see only the surface. The essence of the cities is not so tangible, and that is as robust as ever."
She accepted what he said with a shrug. "How long must we remain here, then?"
"You sought escape from the Lat, did you not? We remain here until the Lat leave the planet."
"You do not know when that will be?"
"It will be soon, I am sure. Either they will become bored with the game or we will. Then the game will end."
"With how many dead?"
"None, I hope."
"You can resurrect everyone?"
"Certainly."
"Even the denizens of your menageries?"
"Not all. It depends how solidly they have made an impression on our own memories, you see. Our rings work from our minds, to achieve the reconstructions."
She did not pursue the topic. "We seem as thoroughly marooned now at the End of Time as we did at the Beginning," she said moodily. "How few are our moments of ordinary living…"
"That will change. These are particularly agitated days. Brannart explained that the chronological fluctuations are unusually persistent. We must all agree to stop travelling through time for a while, then everything will be back to normal."
"I admire your optimism, Mr. Carnelian."
"Thank you, Amelia." He began to walk again. "This is the very city where I was conceived, the Iron Orchid told me. With some difficulty, it seems."
She looked back. Mr. Underwood still sat upon the memory bank, deep in conversation. "Should we leave him?"
"We can return for him later."
"Very well."
They stepped upon thin silver surfaces which creaked as they crossed, but did not crack. They ascended a flight of ebony stairs, towards an ornamental bridge.
"It would seem fitting," said Jherek, "if I were to propose formally to you here, Amelia, as my father proposed to my mother."
"Your father?"
"A mystery my mother chooses to perpetuate."
"So you do not know who —"
"I do not."
She pursed her lips. "In Bromley such a fact would be sufficient to put a complete bar on marriage, you know."
"Truly?"
"Oh, yes."
"But we are not in Bromley," she added.
He smiled. "Indeed, we are not."
"However…"
"I understand."
"Please, continue…"
"I was saying that it would seem fitting that I should ask you, here in this city where I was conceived, for your hand in marriage."
"Should I ever be free to give it, you mean?"
"Exactly."
"Well, Mr. Carnelian, I cannot say that this is sudden. But…"
"Mibix dug frishy hrunt!" said a familiar voice, and across the bridge came marching Captain Mubbers and his men, armed to the teeth and looking not a little put out.
16. The Skull Beneath the Paint
When Captain Mubbers saw them he stopped suddenly, aiming his instrument-weapon at Jherek.
Jherek was almost pleased to see him. "My dear Captain Mubbers…" he began.
"Mr. Carnelian! He is armed!"
Jherek could not quite understand the point of her excitement. "Yes. The music they produce is the most beautiful I have ever heard."
Captain Mubbers plucked a string. There came a grinding noise from the bell-shaped muzzle of his weapon; a slight fizzle of blue sparks appeared for a moment around the rim. Captain Mubbers uttered a deep sigh and threw the thing to the flagstones of the bridge. Similar grindings and fizzlings came from the other instruments held by his men.
Popping a translation pill into his mouth (he had taken to carrying them everywhere just recently) Jherek said:
"What brings you to the city, Captain Mubbers?"
"Mind your own smelly business, sonny jim," said the leader of the space-invaders. "All we armjoint want to do now is find a shirt-elastic way out!"
"I can't understand why you wanted to come in, though…" He glanced apologetically at Mrs. Underwood, who could not understand anything that was being said. He offered her a pill. She refused. She folded her arms in an attitude of resignation.
"Spoils," said another of the Lat.
"Shut it, Rokfrug," Captain Mubbers ordered.
But Rokfrug continued:
"The knicker-patch place seemed so rotten-well protected that we thought there was bound to be something worth having here. Just our shirt-elastic luck —"
"I said shut it, arse-brain!"
But Captain Mubbers' men seemed to be losing faith in his authority. They crossed their three eyes in a most offensive manner and made rude gestures with their elbows.
"Weren't you already sufficiently successful elsewhere?" Jherek asked Rokfrug. "I thought you were doing extremely well with the destruction, the rape and so on…"
"Pissing right we were, until…"
"Cork your hole, bum-face!" shouted his leader.
"Oh, elbow-off!" retorted Rokfrug, but seemed aware that he had gone too far. His voice became a self-pitying mumble as Captain Mubbers gazed disapprovingly back at him. Even his fellows plainly thought Rokfrug's language had put him beyond the pale.
"We're under a bit of a strain," said one of them, by way of apology.
"Who wouldn't be?" Captain Mubbers kicked petulantly at his abandoned weapon. "All the farting trouble we went to to get knicker-patching back to our ship in the first place…"
"…and everything we laid waste to crapping re-appearing," complained Rokfrug, evidently glad to find a point of agreement with his captain.
"…and all our puking prisoners suddenly disappearing…" added another.
"What's the point of it?" Captain Mubbers asked Jherek plaintively. "When we sighted this planet we thought looting it'd be as easy as wiping your bum."
"Ever since," said Rokfrug, "we've been buggered about. These people haven't got the shirt-elastic they were born with. No common sense. How can you terrorize people who keep laughing at you? Besides, the scenery keeps changing…"
"It's a Planet of Illusions," said Captain Mubbers portentously. His pupils darted about in his single eye. "I mean, this is probably another of their traps." He focussed on Jherek. "Is it? You seem a decent sort of bugger, basically. Is it?"
"I don't think anyone's been deliberately misleading you," Jherek told him. "In fact, there seems to have been an effort to accommodate you. What exactly happened? Who stopped you?"
"Well, it was half-and-half. Partly we just ran out of farting steam," Rokfrug said. "Then these soppy little round buggers arrived. They —"
Mrs. Underwood was tapping Jherek urgently on the arm.
He turned, at last, to look at her. Plodding up the steps behind them, grim-faced and triumphant, was Inspector Springer, Sergeant Sherwood and the party of constables.
"Gee noo fig tendej vega!" said Inspector Springer.
"Flow hard!" exclaimed Mrs. Underwood.
It was time for Jherek to swallow a fresh pill.
"Led us straight to 'em, didn't you?" Inspector Springer waved his men forward. "Shackle 'em, lads!"
The constables, moving like automata, pressed forward to arrest the unresisting Lat.
"I knew you'd arrange a meeting sooner or later," Inspector Springer told Jherek. "That's why I let you get away."
"But how were you able to follow us, Inspector?" Mrs. Underwood asked.
"Commandeered a vehicle," Sergeant Sherwood told her importantly.
"Whose?"
"Oh — 'is…" A thumb was jerked backward.
Both Jherek and Amelia turned and looked below. There stood the Duke of Queens, wearing a bright pastel blue uniform not dissimilar in cut to Sergeant Sherwood's. As they saw him he gave a cheerful wave of his bright yellow truncheon and blew his silver whistle.
"Good heavens!" she exclaimed.
"We've made 'im an honorary constable, 'aven't we, Inspector?" said Sergeant Sherwood.
"There's no 'arm in 'umorin' 'em, sometimes." Inspector Springer smiled to himself. "If it's to your advantage."
"Kroofrudi hrunt!" said Captain Mubbers as he was led away.
The city shuddered and groaned. A sudden darkness came and went. Jherek noticed that everyone's skins seemed ghastly pale, almost blue, and the light gave their eyes a peculiar flat sheen, so that they were like the eyes of statues.
"Cripes," said Sergeant Sherwood. "What was that?"
"The city —" Mrs. Underwood whispered. "It is so still. So silent." She moved closer to Jherek. She gripped his arm. He was pleased to comfort her. "Does this often happen?"
"To my knowledge, no…"
Everyone had stopped moving, even the Duke of Queens, below. The Lat grunted nervously to one another. The mouths of the majority of the constables hung open.
Another great shudder. Somewhere in the distance a piece of metal rattled and then fell with a crash, but that was the only sound.
Jherek pressed her towards the stair. "We had better get to the ground, I think. If that is the ground."
"An earthquake?"
"The world is too old for earthquakes, Amelia."
They hurried down the steps and their action lent motion to the others, who followed.
"Harold must be found," said Mrs. Underwood. "Is there danger, Mr. Carnelian?"
"I do not know."
"You said the city was safe."
"From the Lat." He could scarcely bear to look at her deathly-pale skin. He blinked, as if blinking would dispel the scene, but the scene remained.
They reached the Duke of Queens. The Duke stroked his beard, which had gone a seedy sort of purple colour. "I stopped by at your palace, Jherek, but you had gone on. Inspector Springer told me that he, too, was looking for you, so we followed in your wake. It took a while to find you. You know what these cities are like." He fingered his whistle. "Wouldn't you say this one was behaving a bit oddly, at present, though?"
"Collapsing?"
"Possibly — or undergoing some sort of radical change. The cities are said to be capable of restoring themselves. Could that be it?"
"There is no evidence…"
The Duke nodded. "Yet it can't be breaking down. The cities are immortal."
"Breaking down superficially, perhaps."
"One hopes that is all it is. You do look sickly, Jherek, my darling."
"We all do, I think. The light."
"Indeed." The Duke replaced his whistle in his pocket. "Those aliens of mine escaped, you know. While the Lat were on the rampage. They got to their own ship, with Yusharisp and Mongrove."
"They've left?"
"Oh, no! They're spoiling everything. The Lat must be annoyed. They look a bit annoyed, don't they? Yusharisp and company have taken over!" The Duke laughed, but the sound was so unpleasant, even to his own ears, that he stopped. "Ha, ha…"
The city seemed to lurch, as if the entire structure slipped downhill. They recovered their balance.
"We'd better proceed to the nearest exit," said one of the constables in a hollow voice. "Walking, not running. As long as nobody panics, we'll be able to evacuate the premises in no time at all."
"We've got what we came for," agreed Sergeant Sherwood. His uniform had turned a luminous grey. He kept brushing at it, as if he thought the colour was dust clinging to the material.
"Where did we leave the whatsit?" Inspector Springer removed his bowler hat and wiped the inner band with a handkerchief. He looked enquiringly at the Duke of Queens. "Attention there, Special Constable!" His grin was unspontaneous and horrible. "The airship thing?" There had never been jocularity so false.
For a moment the Duke of Queens was so puzzled by the inspector's manner that he merely stared.
"The airship, ho, ho, ho, what brought us 'ere!" Inspector Springer replaced his hat and swallowed rapidly two or three times.
The Duke was vague. "Over there, I think." He rotated slowly, gesturing with his truncheon (which had turned brown), seeking his bearings. "Or was it that way?"
"Cor blimey!" said Inspector Springer in disgust.
"Mibix?" Captain Mubbers spoke absently, as one whose mind is on other things. He returned to chewing on the metal of his hand-cuffs.
The ground made a moaning sound and shivered.
"Harold." Mrs. Underwood plucked at Jherek's sleeve. He noticed that the white linen of his suit had become a patchy green. "We must find him, Mr. Carnelian."
As Jherek and Amelia began to run back to where they had left her husband Inspector Springer also broke into a trot, closely followed by his men, carrying the muttering but unresisting Lat between them, and lastly by the Duke of Queens who was beginning to cheer up at the prospect of action. Action, sensation, was his lifeblood; he wilted without it.
As Jherek and Amelia ran, they heard the piercing eery tones of the Duke's whistle and his lusty voice crying: "Halloo! View halloo!"
Tiny whispering noises issued from the ground, with each step that they made. Something hot and organic seemed at one point to be pulsing beneath their feet. They reached the plain of rotting metal. Harold Underwood could be distinguished through the murky semi-darkness, still deep in conversation with his friend, the rock. He looked up. "Ha!" His tone was kindlier. "So you are all here, now. It says something, does it not, for our earthly hypocrisies?" Evidently the rock had made no real impression on his convictions.
The plain gasped, gave way and became a mile-wide pit.
"I think I'd better make a new air-car," said the Duke of Queens, coming to a sudden halt.
Harold Underwood crossed to the lip of the pit and stared down. He scratched his hay-coloured hair, disturbing the parting. "So there's another level, at least," he mused. "I suppose one should be relieved." He made to investigate further but did not demur when his wife gently drew him back.
The Duke of Queens was twisting all his rings. "Do our rings not work in the city itself?" he asked Jherek.
"I can't remember."
At their backs a building silently burst. They watched the debris float by overhead. Jherek noticed that all their skins now had a mottled, glossy appearance, like mother-of-pearl. He moved closer to Amelia, who still clutched her husband (the only member of the party who seemed serene). They began to move away from the pit, skirting the city proper.
" It is rare that the city's power is overtaxed ," said Harold Underwood's rocky confidante. " Who could need such energy ?"
"You know what is causing this upheaval, then?" Jherek enquired of it.
" No, no. A conversion problem, perhaps. Who can say? You could try the central philosophy department. Except I believe I am all that is left of it. Unless I am the whole of it. Who is to say which is a fragment and which the whole? And is the whole contained in every fragment or a fragment in the whole, or are whole and fragment different, not in terms of size or capacity, but in essential qualities…? "
Regretting his impoliteness, Jherek continued on past the rock. "It would be wonderful to discuss these points," he apologized, "but my friends…"
"The circle is the circle," Harold Underwood said. "We shall be back again, no doubt. Farewell, for the moment." Humming to himself, he allowed Jherek and Amelia to lead him off.
" Indeed, indeed. The nature of reality is such that nothing can, by definition, be unreal, if it exists, and since anything can exist if it can be conceived of, then all that we say is unreal is therefore real… "